LockerGnomeTech news and nostalgia for today's technology professionals
Subscribe

Search

Retrocommodore-64apple-ii

The $595 Commodore 64 Put Custom Sound Beside RAM That Cost Apple Buyers Far More

Engineers’ interviews and Steve Wozniak’s own hardware explanation show two ways of making a home computer affordable, expandable and musical.

Chris Pirillo at a shop counter weighs a small brown Commodore 64 with a short stack of coins against a beige Apple II with a towering stack.
Illustration: LockerGnome

The C64’s 64K was right there in the sales pitch. Commodore put memory, graphics and sound into a box priced below an earlier Apple II’s bare starting configuration. The sound hardware helps explain what a buyer got beyond the memory figure.

The Apple price list printed in July 1977 BYTE ties $1,298 to 4K and $2,638 to 48K. Comparing the cheaper configuration’s price with the expensive one’s memory creates a machine Apple never offered at that price. The same table distinguishes complete systems from boards: the 4K board alone cost $598. A loose motherboard and a complete computer deserve separate shopping lists.

Commodore’s 1982 brochure specifies a 6581 Sound Interface Device with three independent voices, four waveforms and programmable envelopes. A program could shape how a note started, held and faded. The machine also offered eight movable sprites for animation. These capabilities came in the standard computer, giving software makers something specific to design around.

Steve Wozniak’s own Apple II system description, published in May 1977 BYTE, explains a different sound mechanism. Accessing a particular memory location toggled the speaker connection. Producing a tone required the program to keep toggling it at an audible rate. The program was doing the repetitive work needed to make the speaker sing, while Commodore later supplied dedicated synthesizer hardware.

Wozniak also describes sharing memory access between the processor and display circuitry. The video generator used the portion of a processor cycle otherwise occupied by internal housekeeping, and scanning display memory supplied the refresh that dynamic RAM required. His compact design made one mechanism perform several jobs; a comparison based only on sound chips would miss that ingenuity.

Commodore had an advantage outside the case too. IEEE Spectrum’s engineering interviews describe a chip-fabrication line on the premises. Engineers could isolate a circuit into a test chip, with an emergency turnaround as short as four days. Development used otherwise idle capacity, and manufacturing the chips internally avoided a supplier’s markup. David Ziembicki’s description of the silicon expense was wonderfully plain: “It’s only sand.”

The company still needed to turn that access into an inexpensive computer. The same account reports a $130 initial production-cost target and a $135 result. It also describes using the VIC-20’s case and board dimensions to speed development. Owning the chip operation gave Commodore choices; keeping the surrounding product simple helped those choices reach a home buyer’s budget.

Apple was selling another kind of room to grow. Its 1978 brochure lists eight accessory expansion slots and suggests adding cards for music synthesis, printing, controlling electrical outlets and communicating with another computer. The brochure also says a television required an RF modulator that was not supplied. Accessories could expand the machine’s possibilities and the receipt at the same time.

These are nominal prices separated by five years of changing technology. They cannot tell us how much of the gap belongs to RAM economics, chip ownership or each company’s product decisions. They do expose a useful question for the next computer purchase: which capabilities come in every box, and which will become another order after the box arrives?

More Retro

Every Retro story →