LockerGnomeTech news and nostalgia for today's technology professionals
Subscribe

Search

Hardware

Janet Jackson’s Rhythm Nation could crash laptops, so the fix filtered the music

A Windows XP support anecdote led to a failed reproduction and a mechanical-engineering explanation, while the computer manufacturer’s identity remains deliberately withheld.

Chris Pirillo holds a shaking laptop steady with both hands as a loud boombox beside him blasts sound waves at it
Illustration: LockerGnome

The storage failure arrived through the speakers. In Raymond Chen’s account of Rhythm Nation crashing certain old laptops, the cheaper fix lived in audio software. A computer could apparently need a music filter for reasons that had nothing to do with parental controls.

Chen’s original August 2022 post traces the story to a colleague’s Windows XP support experience. A major manufacturer found that playing Janet Jackson’s video crashed some of its laptops, then found susceptible competitors’ machines. The revealing observation was a nearby laptop crashing while another machine played the video. The sound could reach the drive without the receiving computer opening the file at all.

The account identifies a model of 5400 rpm laptop hard drive with a natural resonant frequency present in the song. The manufacturer’s workaround detected and removed the offending frequencies in its playback pipeline. That fixed a very specific route into the failure, leaving the machine’s mechanical susceptibility in place.

His September follow-up adds the reproduction that did not reproduce it. Dave Plummer had tried a full-size drive. Kai, Chen’s source, pointed out that the affected drives were small-form-factor models. Extra mass changes resonance and adds damping; a different drive is a materially different test, even if both devices answer to the name “hard disk.”

Adding ballast to the laptop drive would compromise the small size and low weight it was meant to provide. A different mount could mean a redesigned chassis and renewed testing. Fixing an audio path is an attractive engineering choice when the alternative sends the hardware back through manufacturing changes. Your music player gets a quiet alteration so the rest of the laptop can keep its existing shape.

The mechanical question has research behind it. In a study of a 2.5-inch laptop drive, P. Tanthanasirikul and N. Ajavakom measured component vibration and energy transmission. They examined the top cover, platter and actuator assembly, finding that the platter supplied the main vibration source in their experiment and that some component natural frequencies increased the overall vibration. That paper studies drive mechanics; it does not identify Chen’s unnamed laptop or independently recreate the Janet Jackson crash.

Chen connects the musical side to Adam Neely’s analysis: the video uses A=450 tuning rather than the usual A=440. He reports Neely’s comparison between a low E in that tuning and the drive research. The explanation ties the unusual input to the mechanical response, although readers still lack the affected model number needed for an exact reconstruction.

Chen calls the audio change “a mitigation, not a solution.” His correction also limits the damage claim: the disruption could make a critical operating-system read fail, with normal drive operation returning when the sound stopped. Permanent destruction is not required to explain the crash. That leaves an awkward maintenance question for any similar workaround: when the hardware changes, who still knows why the filter was installed?

More Hardware

Every Hardware story →